During the same week, that I had my Provincial visiting, there were two other visitors as well. They were representing two of Caritas Thailand's major partners from Europe. Both are major contributors to our good work here with migrants. These two visits were hard work but enjoyable and most worthwhile for the progress of our mission.
Both visits involved honest talking on issues. In a place like Thailand, talking is not so direct and definitely Thais act against any confrontational talk even when the topic is serious and needs to be faced for future good purposes. So when my boss asked the western European, female officer about supporting certain work financially and was told in one sentence that there was no money available for his request, I thought to myself how refreshing to have such directness and clarity.
However, this was not so refreshing for my Thai boss. Knowing him well, I would say that he was in a state of shock on receiving a response that was so direct and so strongly "No". His immediate response was to talk about our relationship with this European Church partner in pure money terms. I was shocked to hear even a professional relationship within the Church to be simply reduced to money.
What about the relationships among colleagues? What about the hard work over the years? What about the generosity of the people in their giving? What about all the benefits received through long years of the relationship? What about the laughs and friendships shared? All reduced to money. Beyond the gracefulness and the dignity of a Thai, they can be quite ruthless when it comes to business.
It reminds me that a dominant model of Church I experience here is that of Church doing business. It is a harsh reality but that is the way it is.
I am John Murray, an Australian, Catholic priest of the Order of St Augustine. I live and work in Thailand and have been here since October 2005. I have many stories from my life journey and would simply like to share some of them. So hope you enjoy and go away sometime with a smile or a helpful little insight.
We gather
to give thanks for my 25 years.
Wednesday, February 25, 2015
Thursday, February 19, 2015
A week of visitors
![]() |
| Fr Dave, my Provincial, visiting a refugee community learning centre. |
Well, of course, not every western guy coming this way fits this category. During the past week, just one such example of a good western guy here in my Bangkok was Dave, my Provincial. He was only here for a short visit to see me in my surrounds. So, on Monday, I took him to see a couple of sites of my ministry so that he could have an idea of what I do and whom I help. The exposure featured visiting a learning centre for refugee children. These centres are within the refugee communities and run by the communities themselves in response to a desperate and real need of their people - education for their children. Dave was touched by the experience and spoke so tenderly with the children he met. I was impressed.
The photo shows him with what I would name as the CEO of the learning centre we visited. This guy may be seen as a refugee but he is much more. He is kind and capable, dedicating himself to helping his fellow men and women. He sees a need and does something about it and he continues to do just that even while here as part of the refugee community. His present harsh reality does not stop him from doing what he does best - community organising and helping the people to empower them and raise them up. This he does even when caught up in his own suffering and troubles.
As I told Dave, if we were refugees in this guy's home country, he would be helping us. He is one of those amazing people not dragged down by their own story of hardship, being able to raise above what he endures to keep doing the right thing by others. I am sure Dave has returned home well remembering this guy, among the many he saw caught up in the rather desperate and tragic lot that is a refugee's.
For the record, Dave was one of my many welcome visitors. He can come again.
Wednesday, February 11, 2015
Hard to find a good man in Bangkok
I found an article of interest on a local western news site written by an European woman living here. Her theme was to ask why it was hard for a farang woman in Bangkok to find a good farang man. Well, my Bangkok is full of crazy people and bizarre daily happenings from all sides. I find that if I ever wonder about Thais in the mix of my day, I just turn my attention to some of the crazy farangs here and think then how much sense Thais make in their world.
'Farang' is the local word for westerners. You go down the street and you can hear little children saying out loudly in wonderment - "Farang! Farang!" You sit on the bus and you can hear someone talking about the farang and then you realise - hey, that is me! Farang is sometimes used as a term of derision but it is mainly about expressing amazement or bewilderment. So that is us and I assure you that farangs in Bangkok can be quite amazing or bewildering at times.
One such time, happened last Friday. It is a simple but classic example of how everyday life can be turned on its head into a dramatic scene by bizarre people acting bizarrely. One of my western circle is due to return home and so two friends wanted to meet him for a farewell drink. Simple enough! Innocent enough! Well, not to be so in my Bangkok. As it often does in this my wide friendship group, the story went sour when the one leaving took offence at an email and decided for good reason not to go. Trouble was that he did not bother to communicate this. So his two friends were waiting at the bar as arranged. After waiting an hour, one of these two rang me to find out what was happening. By chance, I was able to say that their friend was not going. This started the farang at the other end of the phone to rave on in a rage - not about their friend standing them up but about their being stuck in a bar that lacked good, draught beer. After all, they only chose that bar because of their 'no show' friend.
I wondered what was going on. This was a scene from a TV comedy. The huge verbal upset focused on the beer and the three never talked with each other about their failed appointment but with me who was not even going. All I can say is that my Bangkok can be bizarre and has more than its share of western men who are really boys.
'Farang' is the local word for westerners. You go down the street and you can hear little children saying out loudly in wonderment - "Farang! Farang!" You sit on the bus and you can hear someone talking about the farang and then you realise - hey, that is me! Farang is sometimes used as a term of derision but it is mainly about expressing amazement or bewilderment. So that is us and I assure you that farangs in Bangkok can be quite amazing or bewildering at times.
One such time, happened last Friday. It is a simple but classic example of how everyday life can be turned on its head into a dramatic scene by bizarre people acting bizarrely. One of my western circle is due to return home and so two friends wanted to meet him for a farewell drink. Simple enough! Innocent enough! Well, not to be so in my Bangkok. As it often does in this my wide friendship group, the story went sour when the one leaving took offence at an email and decided for good reason not to go. Trouble was that he did not bother to communicate this. So his two friends were waiting at the bar as arranged. After waiting an hour, one of these two rang me to find out what was happening. By chance, I was able to say that their friend was not going. This started the farang at the other end of the phone to rave on in a rage - not about their friend standing them up but about their being stuck in a bar that lacked good, draught beer. After all, they only chose that bar because of their 'no show' friend.
I wondered what was going on. This was a scene from a TV comedy. The huge verbal upset focused on the beer and the three never talked with each other about their failed appointment but with me who was not even going. All I can say is that my Bangkok can be bizarre and has more than its share of western men who are really boys.
Wednesday, February 4, 2015
We think we can save the world or we do our little bit
![]() |
| Bangkok Post - Sex workers waiting outside a bar for customers. |
The prupose of my writing is not to pursue a line of advocacy but to approach the issue based on my work experience in NGO world and on reading an article in UCAN (Catholic Asia News).
The article clearly states that why women here do this is to fulfill their duties to their family. Sex work is the only way they see to "rescue their families from poverty". This is based on the strong local cultural forces placed on children to personally look after their parents and family. This responsibility remains very real and becomes a burden for many when the children themselves are poor or lack resources for a livelihood. The article concludes with:
"Sleeping with strangers and risking abuse should be a woman's last resort. Society must do everything it can to equip women with the necessary tools to realize their full potential. If it fails to do that, it has no right to pass judgment."
Then there is my little world wherein this is a major issue that demands a response on the part of the Church. My response seems to focus on meetings, discussions, trainings and producing documents. All is very needed in the overall process but I wonder where is the actual hands on action happening, finding it frustrating thinking to myself - Let's get on and do it!
In the midst of all this, the reality sinks in when I remember how a missionary priest doing great work here faced a huge dilemma in his place of mission in a port and industrial centre in southern Thailand. He was made aware that underage Burmese females were being used as sex workers in the town. He pleaded to me - "What can I do?" The dilemma was that he was a foreigner in Thailand and the local trade was being run by the police. As foreigners, our voice is limited. If the priest spoke out too loudly, he faced being moved out and having his mission closed. This would mean that all the good work being done would be stopped while the local sex trade would continue to flourish. There is no black and white here. Evil is evil but any response on the ground is being made in a murky world that is very grey.
In my line of work, some practitioners may be seen from the outside as saving the world. The reality is that we just do our bit as best we can and keep doing it, hopefully better and better. We can't save the world, nor is that our responsibility.
Wednesday, January 28, 2015
Look at what neglect can do
| A typical Yangon street |
Coming from Bangkok, a huge city full of bitumen and concrete, what struck me was that here is a city with trees, parks and lakes. As the country opens up and the city faces needed development, I only hope that progress does not destroy its greenness as it is such a gift of nature and so refeshing to experience. It is actually life-giving. I also saw the grand, old buildings from colonial days. They now stand in disrepair, being testaments to what was.
Present day Yangon, standing like the old colonial buildings in somewhat disrepair and in need of a good spring clean, has such potential to be both a great and beautiful, world city. It has obviously paid the price of neglect, suffering under over 50 years of military rule where no one paid any loving attention to it. The basics of city services and infrastructure, let alone city beautification, were just ignored as money was used to build up the military and the wealth of its generals.
As I left Yangon last night, I reflected on what neglect can do not only to a city but to us. Neglect leads to decay, to growing old and death before it is really due to take place. I saw that in the streets and buildings of Yangon with its dirty, narrow, crowded streets, traffic, old cars and buses, rubbish just lying around.
As it faces needed development, the question remains what is the answer for a fruitful future. It is not just rampant development, pulling down and building up. It is about much more. You want to save what is good and enhance the beauty of its people whom I found to be warm, open and friendly, even in the midst of such public neglect and decay.
This is about much more than a city. It is about its people. The lesson of a Yangon is a lesson for humanity. Neglect destroys and leads to no life-giving future. Here a city is teaching us about life.
Wednesday, January 21, 2015
This visit is really for me. I'm learning
During his just completed visit to the Philippines, Pope Francis gave this line to Cardinal Tagle of Manila when asked by the cardinal how he was doing after being to Tacloban, the site of devastation following Super Typhoon Yolanda, and experiencing for himself while there his first typhoon. That one line hit me and stays with me. This visit is for him and he is learning from it. Such honesty, such transparency of a human being, such humility. Wow!
What also stays with me is how he naturally responded to the overwhelming suffering of the people. He didn't preach at them or try to give answers or tell them what to do but just was with them in their suffering, sharing tears and showing compassion. He then spoke of how important it is to be able to cry with a suffering people and of a God with them in the midst of their suffering. He is naming how human suffering touches us in an authenically human way and how our response as pastors of each other is to make ourselves vulnerable for the sake of others.
This is a truly great man, a man who naturally shares his humanity, a man of compassion. I see him as our teacher, showing us the way to be decent human beings and to be pastors who spread the good news.
He keeps making these incredible statements. He said while in the Philippines that if you take away the poor you have no gospel.
I feel the need to say little this week but just share so that I can savour the message of Pope Francis for us. The key is not just what he does nor talking about how great a man he is. Rather even more deeply, it is about how he shows us the way to be Christians of integrity and compassion. We can't just leave it all to him. He doesn't want that either. We need to do our bit where we are. This is not just about having a great pope but more importantly about having a pope who reminds us who we be to be church, to be authenically human in a suffering world.
What also stays with me is how he naturally responded to the overwhelming suffering of the people. He didn't preach at them or try to give answers or tell them what to do but just was with them in their suffering, sharing tears and showing compassion. He then spoke of how important it is to be able to cry with a suffering people and of a God with them in the midst of their suffering. He is naming how human suffering touches us in an authenically human way and how our response as pastors of each other is to make ourselves vulnerable for the sake of others.
This is a truly great man, a man who naturally shares his humanity, a man of compassion. I see him as our teacher, showing us the way to be decent human beings and to be pastors who spread the good news.
He keeps making these incredible statements. He said while in the Philippines that if you take away the poor you have no gospel.
I feel the need to say little this week but just share so that I can savour the message of Pope Francis for us. The key is not just what he does nor talking about how great a man he is. Rather even more deeply, it is about how he shows us the way to be Christians of integrity and compassion. We can't just leave it all to him. He doesn't want that either. We need to do our bit where we are. This is not just about having a great pope but more importantly about having a pope who reminds us who we be to be church, to be authenically human in a suffering world.
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Today has been a good day
I am following my philosophy for this year to take more time out. With an old friend in town on his way back to Australia after being in Rome for a conference for priests, I had a perfect opportunity to take a day off and relax and unwnd. So out I went to the airport hotel, where he was for the day, to have lunch with my friend. It was such good fun to catch up with someone whom I had not seen for over 10 years.
It was a much appreciated time after facing two huge days of trying to be a manager in a Thai workplace. Refreshing even!
Now, what were these two days? In the midst of much work activity, I was involved in or observing the Thai process in my office for making a decision on staff salary increases for 2015. What I saw I judged to be quite bizarre. I would think it to be a delicate matter. I would think that it could be dealt with by looking up pay scales but there is no such thing. Then I would think one would proceed in a specifically chosen and planned way that respects the important and delicate nature of the task. There was none of this.
What transpired was that the Thai employer, the bishop, entrusted senior Thai staff to run their process of assessing staff salaries and report to him. They were part of the decision making that concerned both their peers and themselves. I thought this a grossly unfair burden for them but one they took on with great gusto. But then this was happening in a culture so strongly based on patronage, seniority and hierarchy where ones just accept, at least outwardly, what is presented to them by therir superiors. So they were expected to act but for two reasons. One because they were asked by the bishop. The other was because they were senior in the workplace and so they themselves expected to act on this group task and as well they were expected by the group to act for them.
So the 'gang of three' came up with their agreed recommendations which they presented to the bishop who guess what? He did not approve, saying their increases were far too high. He then took their list and declared his own acceptable level of pay for staff. The three took the list back, agreed to the boss' recommendations of the now reduced increases and presented his list back to him for his approval.
I would say then that it was a process that was not a process. It was about the boss having control all the time under the guise of teamwork. I believe this to be more than just a bizarre practice but to be unprofessional and questionable as it takes an integral and valued, employer responsibility of upholding justice for all staff and uses it to remind the staff who is in control. All along, the boss set the agenda and was making the decision. The boss' agenda was to give pay increases to staff but it was much more than that. It was even about more than just work hard and getting paid for that.
It was a strange experience for me as I tried to understand what was happening and assert as best I could all along my one principle to see that all staff were treated fairly and justly. It was an experience of being here where you are included but you are not and where you see how the culture of position and status acts in its own way to protect its own interests.
I was exhausted at the end of all this. So my day off was a needed day, a day to take time away and out and be in a different place in life.
It was a much appreciated time after facing two huge days of trying to be a manager in a Thai workplace. Refreshing even!
Now, what were these two days? In the midst of much work activity, I was involved in or observing the Thai process in my office for making a decision on staff salary increases for 2015. What I saw I judged to be quite bizarre. I would think it to be a delicate matter. I would think that it could be dealt with by looking up pay scales but there is no such thing. Then I would think one would proceed in a specifically chosen and planned way that respects the important and delicate nature of the task. There was none of this.
What transpired was that the Thai employer, the bishop, entrusted senior Thai staff to run their process of assessing staff salaries and report to him. They were part of the decision making that concerned both their peers and themselves. I thought this a grossly unfair burden for them but one they took on with great gusto. But then this was happening in a culture so strongly based on patronage, seniority and hierarchy where ones just accept, at least outwardly, what is presented to them by therir superiors. So they were expected to act but for two reasons. One because they were asked by the bishop. The other was because they were senior in the workplace and so they themselves expected to act on this group task and as well they were expected by the group to act for them.
So the 'gang of three' came up with their agreed recommendations which they presented to the bishop who guess what? He did not approve, saying their increases were far too high. He then took their list and declared his own acceptable level of pay for staff. The three took the list back, agreed to the boss' recommendations of the now reduced increases and presented his list back to him for his approval.
I would say then that it was a process that was not a process. It was about the boss having control all the time under the guise of teamwork. I believe this to be more than just a bizarre practice but to be unprofessional and questionable as it takes an integral and valued, employer responsibility of upholding justice for all staff and uses it to remind the staff who is in control. All along, the boss set the agenda and was making the decision. The boss' agenda was to give pay increases to staff but it was much more than that. It was even about more than just work hard and getting paid for that.
It was a strange experience for me as I tried to understand what was happening and assert as best I could all along my one principle to see that all staff were treated fairly and justly. It was an experience of being here where you are included but you are not and where you see how the culture of position and status acts in its own way to protect its own interests.
I was exhausted at the end of all this. So my day off was a needed day, a day to take time away and out and be in a different place in life.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



