I dedicate this post to Poe Reh in whom I confided on this issue and his advice was to write it up in my blog. So here I am. I went to him to share on my experience of helping urban refugees in Bangkok as he knows the life of camp refugees through being a Karenni from Myanmar. My challenges are with a similar but different population - urban refugees, living in the community in Greater Bangkok.
I have been helping these people for so long that I am hitting a new wall. What is the wall? It is dependency and much more. I would say it is senseless dependency. You help people, they become dependent on you and then the next step arrives, I discover. It is blowing me apart as ones I have helped so long are getting angry with me because I am not helping them as they want. Of course, this is not every urban refugee. There are others you help who stand on their own feet and act for themselves. In doing a simple comparison between the two samples of the population, I am seeing a pattern.
Simply put, it is that if you are a victim back home, you will remain a victim as a refugee in your host country. If you are a success story back home, you will be a success story in your host country. Being a victim is not determined then by your level of suffering - in this case by being a refugee - or any other difficulty or barrier, nor by location, but by who one is in life. Wherever one is or whatever situation one finds oneself in, victim status appears as being the domain not of outside dilemmas and disasters but of who one is and their ability to rise above the mess and meet the challenges of the moment. Carpe diem!
I am John Murray, an Australian, Catholic priest of the Order of St Augustine. I live and work in Thailand and have been here since October 2005. I have many stories from my life journey and would simply like to share some of them. So hope you enjoy and go away sometime with a smile or a helpful little insight.
We gather
to give thanks for my 25 years.
Monday, February 25, 2019
Tuesday, February 19, 2019
Who is the boss?
In the past week, I had an experience that is typical of life in my Bangkok. It is hard for me to explain as it makes no sense when ones tell me one thing, while another dynamic, the direct opposite, is at play. Welcome to my Bangkok where the real is truly amazing.
The situation was this. I needed to replace what for me is an expensive item. So I do what is always best - seek the help of a local - and ask my good Thai friend for his advice. His reply to me was a typical Thai one I hear given to foreign friends - "I follow you". That appears as the local way to be agreeable and never rock the boat. It so fits in with their way of accepting no responsibility in anything for they do not want to be the one taking charge in case something goes wrong. Just hand it over to the supposedly big guy. Being western, I would prefer a more direct or assertive reply. Still that is the way of here.
So off we go to the shopping mall to look and buy. I listen and observe as my friend does the talking with salesmen at the shops. I then make my call as best I can. The deal is done and then my Thai friend tells me what I should have done according to his local knowledge.
I think to myself - Why didn't he tell me what he knew all along to do? Why now after the event does he give the advice I sought? I am then left feeling unsure of myself - Did I make the right decision?
Who is the boss here? Not me. Welcome to my Bangkok.
The situation was this. I needed to replace what for me is an expensive item. So I do what is always best - seek the help of a local - and ask my good Thai friend for his advice. His reply to me was a typical Thai one I hear given to foreign friends - "I follow you". That appears as the local way to be agreeable and never rock the boat. It so fits in with their way of accepting no responsibility in anything for they do not want to be the one taking charge in case something goes wrong. Just hand it over to the supposedly big guy. Being western, I would prefer a more direct or assertive reply. Still that is the way of here.
So off we go to the shopping mall to look and buy. I listen and observe as my friend does the talking with salesmen at the shops. I then make my call as best I can. The deal is done and then my Thai friend tells me what I should have done according to his local knowledge.
I think to myself - Why didn't he tell me what he knew all along to do? Why now after the event does he give the advice I sought? I am then left feeling unsure of myself - Did I make the right decision?
Who is the boss here? Not me. Welcome to my Bangkok.
Tuesday, February 12, 2019
24 Hours
Maybe I have written on this theme before but a basic motto for my Bangkok is your life here can change right around in 24 hours or less. And you know what? It just keeps happening and this week is yet another testament to this personally held motto.
I am getting ready for a visitor from Australia next week. Then Tuesday, there is news that the visit is off, and is off for very good reason. I am involved in planning a key meeting which Tuesday night went from Wednesday to Friday. I plan my work this week to include a colleague now in Yangon for work. Tuesday I find out that his return flight has been put back 24 hours by the airline. So I will not see him this week.
All this does not really matter but it does colour life in my Bangkok and it does make the point. It means always be flexible; always have Plan B or just accept what it is that one can achieve in life and be happy with that.
If I remember correctly, John Lennon had a line - "Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans". My Bangkok tells me how true.
Another basic life motto for me is that control does not work. My Bangkok serves to show how true this is.
I am getting ready for a visitor from Australia next week. Then Tuesday, there is news that the visit is off, and is off for very good reason. I am involved in planning a key meeting which Tuesday night went from Wednesday to Friday. I plan my work this week to include a colleague now in Yangon for work. Tuesday I find out that his return flight has been put back 24 hours by the airline. So I will not see him this week.
All this does not really matter but it does colour life in my Bangkok and it does make the point. It means always be flexible; always have Plan B or just accept what it is that one can achieve in life and be happy with that.
If I remember correctly, John Lennon had a line - "Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans". My Bangkok tells me how true.
Another basic life motto for me is that control does not work. My Bangkok serves to show how true this is.
Tuesday, February 5, 2019
Who am I not?
![]() |
| Underground basilica of early Church in Rome |
What a WOW line!
This was quoted at last week's Caritas International meeting in Rome I attended by a priest from the Vatican Dicastery for the Promotion on Integral Human Development. For him, it is a guiding statement for any work in justice and in working for the progress of people. It comes from a contemporary philosopher.
For me, this says it all. Each person - you and I - has a basic intrinsic worth that cannot be denied. Our worth is such that without us, human history is lacking. Ain't that something!
As I reflected on this insight, I recalled the great line from Nelson Mandela who stressed in his own way that each of us has a contribution to make to the world. He said we could choose two ways. One is the way of false humility where many reason simply - Who am I o do this or say this in response to our world of injustice? Then other way is the way to go. Realize who we are and claim our greatness and understand clearly - Who am I not to make my statement against injustice in our world?
The world needs me. The world needs our voice. Without any of us, history is lacking. Wow!!
So last week, I was in Rome at this intense two day meeting on advocacy with people who have much greater experience and capability in this area of work than I have. I was definitely batting above my weight but I was making my contribution which our world needs. Wow! Ain't that a special and precious gift and responsibility to be treasured and shared? Go for it!
Wednesday, January 30, 2019
Ciao!
As a teenager, I went with my sister, Theresa, to my first concert to see Liberace at Festival Hall in Brisbane. It was great fun and so entertaining. I remember a line he had -
"Never say Arriverderci! Always say Ciao!"
I loved it as it means never say Goodbye but always say See you!
So this week I am in Rome for a short sojourn to go to a two day meeting with Caritas. The other big reason is to see a good friend again who lives there. Both tell me that as always what matters in life is people. Keep the focus while on the journey. So this is a week with a difference. Ciao Bangkok! Ciao Roma! How I love Rime. How I love my friends. How I love helping people. They all give me life.
"Never say Arriverderci! Always say Ciao!"
I loved it as it means never say Goodbye but always say See you!
So this week I am in Rome for a short sojourn to go to a two day meeting with Caritas. The other big reason is to see a good friend again who lives there. Both tell me that as always what matters in life is people. Keep the focus while on the journey. So this is a week with a difference. Ciao Bangkok! Ciao Roma! How I love Rime. How I love my friends. How I love helping people. They all give me life.
Wednesday, January 23, 2019
Home, James!
![]() |
| The only way to go to church - driven in your Bentley. |
It makes me think. There is money in this country, but not only in society, also in its national Church. The disparity seen in its society is merely mirrored in its Church. The elite are not just out there but here with us in Church. Yes, they are loved by God as much as anyone else. That is not an issue. However it does make me think how we all tick. We live in the one society but we are not all treated the same, nor do we treat each other the same. That is what happens continually throughout history. Society is ruled by elites - maybe benevolent, maybe not. In part, that is how societies run. But then in Church?
We are part of the one Church and hear the same words about love but we do not seem to hear the same message. Society is one thing but Church is more specific with a firm purpose set by our following the Jesus of love and mercy. Maybe the one focal purpose for Church may be named by the question - In knowing and accepting God's love, how do we respond to our neighbour?
In grappling with that question, I cannot answer for anyone but I do see what I see and cannot deny my experience. Like any society, here people are people and the mass of people are ordinary citizens living everyday life. There is nothing extraordinary about that but what is different here is the degree of social pressure exerted to maintain the status quo through using strong social control mechanisms and a rigidly conservative education system. This social control is exercised in most subtle but direct ways such that the ordinary citizen is not adversely alerted to what is happening to act against their own right and interest to self-advancement within society. What Sunday reminded me is that Church also acts as a control agent for maintaining the status quo which favours not only the social elite but also the Church institution, or so the hierarchy think.
So the Church is not an active voice for the voiceless here. It does not openly question injustice. It does not stand up for the gospel. Seemingly, the Church more than mirrors the realities of its society. It benefits from these same realities, or does it? The ultimate question is - who does benefit out of all of this?
Tuesday, January 15, 2019
Time for a Reality Check
![]() |
| Hard to see in the Bangkok pollution but you are looking at Icon Siam. |
![]() |
| The home for construction workers in the shadow of Icon Siam. |
There is huge wealth here. You see the the new and high condo buildings; you see the luxury cars; you see the fashion. The reality though is that too much of this wealth lies in the hands of a few, an elite class who enjoy more than their share of the fruits of this land. Thailand is named as the country with the greatest disparity in wealth in the world. The pertinent report named that 1% of the population owns 69% of the country's wealth. Of course, the government was quick to go public, deriding such statistics as ridiculous, but that does not take away from the reality.
True, by far this is not the poorest country in the world. Still this does not take away from the harsh reality defined by ownership of wealth. Beyond this reality, what really concerns me is a mindset that supports and sustains it. This mindset says it is okay for the few to own so much at the expense of others. The few do not care. They lack a sense of the other in their community. The lack of solidarity, the lack of any interest in others, the utter sense of entitlement and being overcome by pursuits for self-aggrandizement are what concern and overtake such an elite set in society.
The concentration of wealth and power are the fruits of such a narrow and self serving mindset which acts to allow such a social wrong to continue. An elitist mindset is for the good of the select few and not for the common good; it serves the status quo and not good change. It acts not only against the good of society but ultimately against the good of the elite themselves. I say this as the basic question ever remains - what is it to be human? And forever, it seemingly will remain unanswered in a world ruled by elites.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




